Four different thermometers were used to measure the temperature of a sample of impure boiling water. The measurements are recorded in the table below.

Thermometer Temperature
Reading 1 Temperature
Reading 2 Temperature
Reading 3
W 100.1°C 99.9°C 96.9°C
X 100.4°C 102.3°C 101.4°C
Y 90.0°C 95.2°C 98.6°C
Z 90.8°C 90.6°C 90.7°C

The actual boiling point of pure water is 100.0°C.

What can be concluded from the data about the reliability and validity of the thermometers?

A.
Thermometer W is the most reliable.
B.
Thermometer X has the highest validity.
C.
Thermometer Z is the most reliable.
D.
Thermometer Y has the highest validity.

Answers

Answer 1
Thermometer Z is the most reliable but has the least validity.Thermometer W has the highest validity.The rank for reliability, from most reliable to least reliable, is:              Z > X > W > YThe rank for validity, from greatest validy to lowest validity is:              W > X > Y > Z

How, explain your answer?

Reliability is another name for the precision of the measurement, and it means how well the value is repeated; this is, how close the different measurements are to each other. If the measurements are close one to each other, then the instrument is precise or reliable (high reliability).

Validity is another name for the accuracy of the measurement; this is, how close the measurement is to the true or accepted value.

With that, we can compare the reliability (precision) and validity (accuracy) of the four different thermometers.

Repeat the table:

Temperatures in °C:

Thermometer  Reading 1   Reading 2   Reading 3

       W                 100.1             99.9             96.9

        X                 100.4           102.3             101.4

        Y                  90.0            95.2             98.6

        Z                  90.8             90.6            90.7

Reliability:

To analyze reliability (precision) we must compare the measures of every thermometer among them. A good approximation can be made calculating the range, i.e. the difference between the largest and the smallest readings:

For W: largest reading - smallest reading = 100.1°C - 96.9°C = 3.2°CFor X: largest reading - smallest reading = 102.3°C - 100.4°C = 1.9°CFor Y: largest reading - smallest reading = 98.6°C - 90.0°C = 8.6°CFor Z: largest reading - smallest reading = 90.8°C - 90.6°C = 0.2°C

Now, you conclude that the most reliable is thermometer Z and the least reliable is thermometer Y. The complete ranking, from most reliable to least reliable is:

Z > X > W > Y

Validity:

To determine validity you must compare the mean of the three measures for each thermometer with the accepted value for the boiling point of pure water (100.0°C).

The mean is the sum of the three readings divided by 3.

The absolute error is calculated with the formula:

absolute error = | accepted value - calculated value |.

The calculated value is the mean.

For W: mean = (100.1 + 99.9 + 96.9)°C / 3 = 99.0°C

                   absolute error = 100.0°C - 99.0°C = 1.0°C

For X: mean = (100.4 + 102.3 + 101.4)°C / 3 = 101.4 °C

                  absolute error = 101.4°C - 100.0°C = 1.4° For Y: mean = (90.0 + 95.2 + 98.6)°C / 3 = 94.6°C

                  absolute error = 100.0°C - 94.6°C = 5.4°C

For Z: mean = (90.8 + 90.6 + 90.7)°C / 3 = 90.7°C

                  absolute error = 100.0°C - 90.7°C = 9.3°C

Now you can rank the thermometers as per their validity (accuracy):

1.0°C < 1.4°C < 5.4°C < 9.3°C

Thus, W is the most accurate, X is the second most accurate, Y is the third, and Z is the least accurate.

To learn more about thermometers click here:

https://brainly.com/question/24189042

#SPJ1


Related Questions

Suppose an mRNA consists of 60 nucleotides; it directs a primary polypeptide chain containing __________ amino acids to be synthesized.​

Answers

An mRNA that consists of 60 nucleotides directs a primary polypeptide chain containing 18 amino acids to be synthesized.​

What is the genetic code?

The genetic code is a series of instructions by which a cell can synthesize proteins through two sequential processes: transcription (mRNA) and translation (protein).

The translation is produced from messenger RNAs (mRNAs), where triples of nucleotides or codons give rise to specific aminoacids.

In conclusion, an mRNA that consists of 60 nucleotides directs a primary polypeptide chain containing 18 amino acids to be synthesized.​

Learn more about translation here:

https://brainly.com/question/17088332

#SPJ1

Which of the following is NOT true of viruses?

A. Some viruses have a membrane envelope.
B. Viruses need a living cell to reproduce.
C. Some viruses live through the lytic cycle.
D. Some viruses contain both DNA and RNA.

Answers

Some viruses contain both DNA and RNA as their genetic material is NOT true of viruses (option D).

What is a virus?

A virus is a non-living entity that needs a suitable host to reproduce its genetic material (DNA or RNA).

Viruses may contain a genetic material composed of other DNA or RNA but not both.

In conclusion, some viruses contain both DNA and RNA as their genetic material is NOT true of viruses (option D).

Learn more about viruses here:

https://brainly.com/question/25236237

#SPJ1

The size of most prokaryotic cells is about _________ in diameter.
1-2µm
3-4µm
4-5µm
2-5µm

Answers

Answer:

option 1

Explanation:

The size of most prokaryotic cells is about in diameter.

1-2µm

The size of most prokaryotic cells is about 1-2µm in diameter. Therefore option A is correct.

Most prokaryotic cells are relatively small, typically ranging in diameter from 1 to 2 micrometers (µm). Prokaryotes are unicellular organisms without a true nucleus or membrane-bound organelles.

Their small size is advantageous as it allows for efficient nutrient uptake and waste elimination, facilitating rapid growth and replication.

Despite their small size, prokaryotic cells are highly diverse and can be found in various environments, including soil, water, and even within the human body.

Therefore option A is correct.

Know more about prokaryotic cells:

https://brainly.com/question/7153285

#SPJ3

ASAPPPP EASYYYY ILL MARK BRAINLY
Select all direct effects increasing UVR have on animals?
is
a) reduces immunity to diseases
a direct effect increasing UVR have on animals

Answers

a. reduces immunity to diseases

The effect increasing UVR has on animals is reducing immunity to diseases.

What is UVR?

A body could be heated to an incandescent temperature to generate UV radiation, which seems to be the case with solar UV, or an electric current would be sent through a gas, typically vaporized mercury, to generate UV radiation.

What are diseases?

A disease would be a specific aberrant state that adversely affects an organism's structure as well as function on the whole or in part, and which could be not immediately brought on by any external trauma.

Therefore, the correct answer will be an option (a)

To know more about UVR and disease

https://brainly.com/question/13849635

#SPJ2

Preservation of Habitats - Everglades NP, FL. North of the park border, if developers or farmers drain and utilize this land, what will happen to the source of water for the Everglades, and therefore to the ecosystem of the Everglades

Answers

Farmers draining and utilizing the land the Everglades will dry up the source of the water of the Everglades and disrupt the ecosystem of the Everglades.

What is a habitat?

A habitat is an area where living organisms are found and make their home.

The Everglades is an wetland habitat where the land is covered by water most times of the year.

Farmers draining and utilizing the land of the Everglades will result in the source of the water of the Everglades drying which will disrupt the ecosystem of the Everglades.

Learn more about Everglades at: https://brainly.com/question/9423676

#SPJ1

on area is 10m * 10m and 6 quadrants of 0.5 * 0.5m where set randomly and counted six five four three two and one grass respectively how many grasses would be found in the whole area​

Answers

It would be about 30 grasses in the whole area

There are six people in the Fisher family. Olivia and Marcus are the parents. They have four children: Violet, Nathan, Jonas, and Claudia.

Neither Olivia nor Marcus have freckles.

What is Olivia's genotype?
What is Marcus' genotype?
What is the probability that each child has of inheriting freckles?
Both Marcus and Olivia are heterozygous for the hairline trait.

What is the probability that each of their children could inherit a widow's peak?
What is the probability that each of their children could inherit a straight hairline?
What is the probability that each of their children could be homozygous dominant for the trait?
Neither Marcus nor Olivia can roll their tongues.

How many of their children could be born with the ability to roll their tongues?
How many of their children could be heterozygous?
What is the genotype of the whole family?
All four children have dimples.

What is likely the genotypes of their parents?
Do we know with certainty that one of the parents has to have dimples?
Both Olivia and Marcus are EE for the earlobe trait.

Among their children, what is the ratio of free earlobes to attached earlobes?
What percentage of the children are homozygous?
Marcus can not detect the bitter taste. Olivia has been found to be able to detect the bitter taste, but she is heterozygous for the trait.

What is the probability that each of their children could taste the ptc paper?
If Violet can not taste the ptc paper, what is Violet's genotype?
Given what you know, how many of the family can taste the ptc paper?

Answers

1.

Freckles are caused by a dominant allele (F).

Marcus and Olivia have recessive homozygotes for the characteristic, ff, if neither of them has freckles.

Olivia's genotype is thus ff.

Marcus has a ff genotype.

Given that they are both recessive homozygotes for the ff gene, there is little chance that their offspring will have freckles.

2.

The straight hairline allele, W is recessive to the widow peak allele, W.

Marcus and Olivia share the hairline trait heterozygosity Ww.

The likelihood of a widow having children is highest when:

Ww = Ww, Ww, Ww, and ww

Widow's peak probability (WW or Ww) equals 3/4

The likelihood that a youngster will have a straight hairline is 1/4.

The likelihood that the offspring will be homozygous

3.

The attached-lobule trait, e, is recessive to the free-lobule trait, E.

The trait, EE, is homozygous dominant in both parents.

One to zero is the ratio of free to connected lobes.

The offspring will be homozygous dominant free lobules, EE, in all cases.

4.

The ability to taste bitter flavors is dominant (T).

Marcus is a recessive homozygote for the trait "tt" since he cannot sense bitterness.

Olivia possesses a "Tt" heterozygote for the trait.

Tt tt equals Tt, Tt, tt, and tt.

There is a 50% chance that each of their kids will try the PTC paper.

Violet's genotype is tt since she cannot taste PTC paper.

5.

T, tongue rolling is a dominant characteristic.

Marcus and Olivia both have tt genotypes since neither of them can roll their tongues.

tt = tt = tt = tt

Therefore;

Their offspring won't be able to roll their tongues.

No hybrids will be born to them.

The entire family shares the genetic tt.

6.

A dimple is a dominant trait (D)

The four youngsters all have dimples.

Therefore,

It's possible that both of their parents carry the dominant allele for the characteristic "DD" or

One of them is heterozygous, or "Dd," and the other is homozygous.

The dominant h0m0zygote "DD" is one of them, while the recessive h0m0zygote "dd" is the other.

Therefore, at least one parent must have a dimple.

learn more about dominant and recessive alleles here: https://brainly.com/question/15726066

#SPJ10

Colorado has a vast population of lodgepole pines. A population of lodgepole pines has been killed in a section of the forest. What is a possible limiting factor of that population?
devastation by the pine bark beetle
Colorado’s long history of acidic soils
genetic variability
shallow root system

Answers

The possible limiting factor is the devastation by the pine bark beetle.

What is a limiting factor?

A limiting factor is any factor that affects the size of a population of organisms which inhibits their growth or even existence.

The possible limiting factor of population of lodgepole pines is the devastation by the pine bark beetle.

This is so because only a section of the population was affected and not the whole.

If it was the Colorado’s long history of acidic soils, genetic variability and shallow root system, the whole population of lodgepole pines would have been affected.

Learn more about population here:

https://brainly.com/question/1437549

#SPJ1

Answer:

a. devastation by the pine bark beetle

Explanation:

The given graph shows the amount of waste generated, dumped and treated in percentage. Identify the reason of low success rate of waste management process. ​

Answers

Waste disposal and waste management are significant problems in today's world. Garbage generation and disposal pose a real threat, resulting in server environmental issues. The issue is not with biodegradable or recycled waste. We recognize the need to reduce non-biodegradable waste. In this only 15% of urban waste is processed, and less than 60% of waste is collected from households.  The correct option is d.

What is waste disposal?

Waste disposal is the collection, processing, recycling, or disposal of human society's waste materials. Waste is classified according to its source and composition.

Waste disposal and waste management are significant problems in today's world. Garbage generation and disposal pose a real threat, resulting in server environmental issues.

The issue is not with biodegradable or recycled waste. We recognize the need to reduce non-biodegradable waste.

In this only 15% of urban waste is processed, and less than 60% of waste is collected from households.

The missing options of the question are attached below

Thus, the correct option is d.

For more details regarding waste management, visit:

https://brainly.com/question/14665452

#SPJ1

Question 7 (True/False Worth 1 points)
(05.03 LC)
The correct way to calculate population density is by dividing the total population by the land area.
O True
O False

Answers

Answer: true

Explanation:

analyze and evaluate whether the examples are likely or not likely to result in differential reproductive success.

answer asap

Answers

The examples that most likely result in differential reproductive success are height, disease-resistant, intelligence level, colorful plumage, etc.

What is Reproductive success?

Reproductive success may be defined as the methodology of the demise of genes to the next generation in a manner that they similarly can pass those genes on to the next generation.

Reproductive success is the outcome of relative fitness which include two parameters such as relative survival and relative reproduction.

Reproductive success is assumed a significant determinant of gatherings that are preferred by the strategy of natural selection.

Therefore, the examples of reproductive success are clearly mentioned above.

To learn more about Reproductive success, refer to the link:

https://brainly.com/question/13022266

#SPJ1

The method of​ _______ is used for tests of hypotheses that three or more population means are equal.

Answers

߷[tex] \huge \tt \:{ \underbrace{ \overbrace {\pink{Answer}}}}[/tex]߷

● The method of " one-way analysis of variance " is used for tests of hypotheses that three or more population means are equal.

Answer:

one-way analysis of variance

Explanation:


———is to animals cells as cellulose is to plant cel

Answers

Answer:

lipids and protein is to animal cells as cellulose is to plant cell

Information collected directly with the senses is

Answers

the answer would be observation

What two layers are the smooth muscle cells arranged in?

Answers

Answer:

The smooth muscle in the intestine is arranged into two layers: an inner circular layer and an outer longitudinal layer.

The two layers that the smooth muscles cells are arranged in are; an inner circular layer and an outer longitudinal layer.

What are the Intestine Muscles?

The smooth muscle cells of the intestine has three layers of smooth muscle that consists of the outer longitudinal, the middle circular, and the inner oblique muscles.

Now, out of all the three layers listed above, the two layers that the smooth muscles cells are arranged in are an inner circular layer and an outer longitudinal layer.

Read more about Intestines' Muscles at; https://brainly.com/question/1204800

#SPJ12

Question 20 of 25
Exponential population growth cannot continue when organisms begin to
O A. adapt
OB. reproduce
OC. compete
OD. mutate

Answers

Oc would be the answer to this question

After absorption, long-chain fatty acids and monoglycerides inside intestinal cells are

Answers

After absorption, long-chain fatty acids and monoglycerides inside intestinal cells are reformed into triglycerides.

Where are long chain triglycerides absorbed?

As previously mentioned, MCTs do not delay gastric emptying and are absorbed faster in the intestine than MCTs, being transported via blood to the liver.

In this case, long-chain triglycerides are oils or fats of vegetable or animal origin, and are obtained from the reaction between a fatty acid and glycerol.

See more about triglycerides at brainly.com/question/13840067

#SPJ11

I need the answer asap

Answers

Answer:

Executive

Explanation:

having the power to put plans, actions, or laws into effect.

Identify the correct statement(s) regarding heritability Heritability is always calculated by a correlation between parental (mid-parent) and offspring traits If heritability is equal to 1, offspring mean is equal to the mean of the original population When heritability is equal to 1, response to selection is equal to selection differential All of the above are correct

Answers

The correct statement regarding heritability is D. All of the above are correct.

What is heritability?

Heritability simply means a measure of how well differences in the genes of people account for the difference in their traits.

In this case, a the options given regarding heritability are correct.

Therefore, the correct option is D.

Learn more about heritability on:

brainly.com/question/198623

#SPJ12

Question 3 of 10
What was the purpose of treating the radish seeds for the lab "Radical
Radishes" with radioactive cobalt-60?
A. To cause mutations in the radish embryos
B. To hybridize normal radish DNA with a radioactive DNA probe
C. To kill all the living microorganisms on the seeds
D. To produce labeled probes with radish DNA
SUBMI

Answers

The purpose of treating the radish seeds with radioactive cobalt-60 is to cause mutations in the radish embryos (Option A).

What is chemical mutagenesis?

Chemical mutagenesis is a technique used in molecular biology laboratories by inducing mutations in germinal cells.

Chemical mutagenesis is very useful to link an anormal phenotype to a mutated gene, an approach known as reverse genetics.

In conclusion, the purpose of treating the radish seeds with radioactive cobalt-60 is to cause mutations in the radish embryos (Option A).

Learn more about Chemical mutagenesis here:

https://brainly.com/question/22733429

#SPJ1

True or false? the chemiosmotic hypothesis states that the synthesis of atp generates a proton gradient that leads to electron flow through an electron transport chain.

Answers

Answer:

False

Explanation:

The chemiosmotic hypothesis states that the flow of electrons through an electron transport chain generates a proton gradient that leads to the synthesis of ATP. A proton gradient across chloroplast and mitochondrial membranes drives ATP synthesis by the enzyme ATP synthase.

Suggest why glucose is converted to glycogen rather than kept as glucose inside the cells

Answers

Explanation:

after a main glucose and the liver and level of blood glucose rise this successful course is guilt with by the glucose lenses which is the liver Converse glucose into glycogen for storage the glucose that is not stole is used to produce energy by a process called glycolysis

What controls differentiation? Choose the correct answer .

Answers

Gene expression controls differentiation of cells. Details about differentiation can be found below.

What is cell differentiation?

Cell differentiation is a cellular process in which the cells of multicellular organisms advance in organization and acquire special organs for specific purposes.

Cell differentiation is what forms specific cells that are adapted to specific roles in multicellular organisms.

However, this process of differentiation is as a result of the expression of genes at different times, since, all cells of an organism contains the same genes.

Learn more about cell differentiation at: https://brainly.com/question/13956392

#SPJ1

Why did problems with low oxygen levels and increasing carbon dioxide levels develop in Biosphere?

Answers

The problem with low oxygen levels and increasing carbon dioxide levels develop in the Biosphere because the oxygen was absorbed by the population of microbes that are growing in an uncontrolled manner and some other concrete structures present in the Biosphere.

What is Biosphere?

A biosphere may be defined as the areas of the surface and atmosphere of the earth or another planet inhabited by living organisms. It may also be regarded as the zone of life on earth.

The amount of carbon dioxide directly depends on the amount of oxygen. If the oxygen level reduces, the level of carbon dioxide will definitely tend to increase.

The level of oxygen accounted as low in the biosphere due to the microbial respiration to a larger extent. And thereby, the level of carbon dioxide increases.

Therefore, it is well described above.

To learn more about Biosphere, refer to the link:

https://brainly.com/question/12467010

#SPJ1

Compare the origins of the common carotid arteries of the fetal pig with those of the human.

Answers

The comparison is that in humans, only one carotid arteries branches from the brachiocephalic artery while for the fetal pig, both arteries branches from the brachiocephalic artery.

What is the comparison of the Arteries?

The difference between the origins of the carotid arteries in the human heart and the fetal pig is that In a human, the right carotid arteries branches from the brachiocephalic artery, while the left common carotid artery comes directly out of  the aortic arch.

Meanwhile, In the fetal pig, both carotid arteries branch from the brachiocephalic artery.

Read more about Arteries at; https://brainly.com/question/64497

#SPJ12

How does a motor neuron work when a mosquito is seen on an arm? it receives stimuli information from the skin and sends it to the brain where it is processed. it receives processed information from the brain, causing the muscles of the arm and hands to remove the mosquito from the arm. it processes information from the stimuli receiver and makes the brain aware that there is a mosquito on the arm. it makes the arm numb from the effect of the mosquito bite.

Answers

The motor neuron work when a mosquito is seen on an arm as it receives processed information from the brain, causing the muscles of the arm and hands to remove the mosquito from the arm. The correct option is B.

What is a motor neuron?

Motor neurons are a type of brain cell that can be found in both the spinal cord and the brain.

The motor neuron work when a mosquito is seen on an arm as it receives processed information from the brain, causing the muscles of the arm and hands to remove the mosquito from the arm.

Thus, the correct option is B.

For more details regarding motor neuron, visit:

https://brainly.com/question/13063876

#SPJ1

Answer:

b is correct

Explanation:

How is nitrogen gas fixed biologically?

A. combustion of fossil fuels
B. decomposition of organic matter
C. respiration of living organisms
D. bacteria in plant roots and soil

Answers

Answer:

D. BACTERIA IN PLANT ROOTS AND SOIL

cells were first discovered when a scientist named _____________ observed cell walls in cork under a microscope

Answers

The cells were first discovered when a scientist named Robert Hooke observed cell walls in cork under a microscope.

Who was Robert Hooke and what was his importance for cytology?

Robert Hooke's observation made it possible to visualize the dead cell walls of cork, even without knowing what the image represented, exactly, and without relating living beings to a cellular composition.

In the beginning, the cell theory was elaborated by the scientist Robert Hooke, in the year 1665. Based on this research, the cell is a morphophysiological unit of all living beings, that is, it corresponds to the smallest unit of life.

See more about Robert Hooke at brainly.com/question/1562414

#SPJ12

A nursing instructor is reviewing the role and function of stem cells in the bone marrow with a group of nursing students. After providing the explanation, the instructor asks the students to use their knowledge of anatomy and physiology to determine an alternate way in which adults with diseases that destroy marrow can resume production of blood cells. Which explanation by the students is correct

Answers

Bone marrow transplant is the alternate way that destroy marrow can resume production of blood cells.

Determine an alternate way for destroy marrow?

A bone marrow transplant, is the treatment and an alternate way that destroy marrow can resume production of blood cells. If a donor is found, your diseased bone marrow is depleted with radiation or chemotherapy and the new bone marrow is transplanted.

So we can conclude that bone marrow transplant is the alternate way that destroy marrow can resume production of blood cells.

Learn more about marrow here: https://brainly.com/question/6197163

#SPJ12

Which statement about generic disease is true
A
B
C

Answers

Answer:

B. Genetic diseases are CURABLE but not TREATABLE.

Other Questions
Refer to the fourth stanza of Lady Freedom Among Us.How does Doves use of figurative language in these lines affect the poem?It shows Dove is critical of Americans who fail to achieve the American Dream.It conveys the idea that, regardless of status, every American deserves equal respect and dignity.It highlights Doves optimism about Americas efforts to restore national monuments.It develops a sarcastic tone regarding Americas ignorance of homelessness in society. In ABC, m Given: NQ is the bisector of ZMNP and ZNMQZNPQProve: MNQ =MNQP One root of f (x) = x cubed 10 x squared minus 25 x minus 250 is x = 10. what are all the roots of the function? use the remainder theorem. 3n-5p+2n=10 solve for n Which characteristics does Gilgamesh display in this passage? Check all that apply. I need help with Algebra every single timePlease help Theo is grounded by his parents for getting bad grades at school. After the first week of being grounded, Theo brought home his new report card with all these. To encourage Theo to get more As, his parents ended his being grounded a week earlier than they had originally stated. Is the punishment by application or by removal? The french government enticed people to go to new france with the offer of what: 100 PTS+BRAINILIEST: Why does it get colder as you go higher through the atmosphere, if you are getting closer to the sun?? Which criterion can be used to prove abc and adc are congruent? triangles, abc and acd, are plotted on a grid that share a common side ac. angles cad and acb are marked congruent. angles cab and acd are marked congruent. a. sss b. aaa c. sas d. asa $30 is taken off the price of a dress. If the new price is now 60% off the original price, what was the original price of the dress. Data erasure software uses standards that are called. There are 164 g H3PO3 formed during areaction. How many moles of HO arerequired? (H3PO3: 82 g/mol) . Bobby and Alice are pushing a stalled car in the same direction. The mass of the car is 2,000 kg. Bobby applies 400 N to the car while Alice applies 300 N. A force created by friction is 500 N in the opposite direction. What is the acceleration of the car? how many populations does america have? If a gene has 9 codons, how many amino acids long would it be? James has been directed by his employer's finance department that they cannot afford to lose any more than 30 minutes of data in the case of a database failure or other catastrophic event. James has updated his corporate business continuity plan and has had his cloud provider update its SLA. What was the metric that was changed Which correctly analyzes each words part of speech in the sentence?During (prep), that (demonstrative adj), epidemic (n), early (adj), warnings (n), circulated (v), widely (adv)During (v), that (demonstrative adj), epidemic (n), early (adv), warnings (n), circulated (v), widely (adj)During (prep), that (article), epidemic (n), early (adv), warnings (v), circulated (v), widely (adj)During (gerund), that (article), epidemic (n), early (adj), warnings (v), circulated (v), widely (adv) Use the graph of the exponential growth functionf(x) = a(2x) to determine which statement is true. f(0) = 2 when a = One-half.f(0) = 3 when a = 3.f(1) = 9 when a = 9.